See also “Hemolytic anemia” under “blood diseases” and “Hemolytic uremic syndrome” under “Kidney diseases”.
Autoimmune diseases are generally understood to be diseaes where the target of the disease is “self” or “self antigen”. Among the many types of autoimmune diseases, there are a number of diseases that are believed to involve T cell immunity directed to self antigens, including multiple sclerosis (MS), Type I diabetes, and rheumatoid arthritis (RA). Automimmune disorders are a significant clinical problem. In the US they are estimated at more than 8.5 million.
Autoimmune diseases, with the exception of rheumatoid arthritis and autoimmune thyroiditis, are individually rare, but together they affect about 5 percent of the population in Western countries. Autoimmune diseases are a poorly understood group of diseases. Mackay (New England J. Medicine, 345(5), 2001).
The autoimmune response underlying a variety of rheumatic diseases, such as with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), is distinguished by the production of antibodies with specificites for molecules involved in regulating the structure and assembly of nucleic acids. For example, the oncogene DEK has been shown to be an autoantigen and anti-DEK autoantibodies are associated with a distinct form of juvenile rheumatoid arthrities with iridocyclitis affecitng young girls (Wichmann, Human Immunology, 60, 1999, 57-62).
Possible Triggers for Autoimmunity and Abnormalities Associated with Automimmune Diseases
1. Molecular mimicry can trigger self-reactive B cells to produce auto-antibodies through linked recognition. For example, antibodies produced in response to streptococcus bacteria cross-react with self-antigens in kidneys, joints and heart resulting in Rheumatic fever. How this can work is the following: When a B cells takes up and presents self antigen to a T cells, T cells do not react (reactive ones were deleted) so there is no Ig production. However, sometimes after infection self antigen gets presented along with the foreign peptide which activates T cells. B cells produce antibodies here against the self-peptide.
2. Bystander Activation: is due to tissue destruction caused by a pathogen which allows self-antigens to be presented in an inflammatory milieu. A DC encounters a microbe and becomes stimulated which activates a T cells. For example, in response to theilers virus which infects neurons in the brain, T cells are recruited by inflammatory mediators. Cytotoxic T cells specific for viral antigens clear the virus. However, a breakdwon in degradation of meline as a consequence of neuronal death autoimmune disease begins mediated by myelinspecific CD4+ T cells. In the first stage, the CD4+ T cells respond to a single dominant eptiope in a myelin protein. Over time, the specificity of the CR4+ T cells response spreads form just one epitope to other epitopes in the same protein and in different proteins.
3. Dysregulation of the Innate Immune System: If infected mice with agonist for TLR 9 no disease. However, TLR 3 or 7 were sufficient. This suggested that getting Type I IFN in vivo might be enough to break the tolerant model. IFN-alpha levels are often increased in SLE pateints. TNF-alpha is increased in RA pateints.
There is growing evidence that TLRs respond to endogenous ligands (as well as TLRs) such as fibrinogen, heat shock proteins, mammalian DNA, etc. This might suggest that the primary lesion in some autoimmune diseases is due to the failure to properly discriminate self versus non-self by the innate immune system.
4. Hygiene Hypothesis: Autoimmunity is a product of both genetic and environmental factors. Interestingly, there has been a steady increase in the prevalence of autoimmune diesease, allergies and inflammatory bowel disease in developed countries. Under the “hygiene hypothesis” is is proposed that microbial exposure prevents immune mediated inflammatory disease. It is beleived that microbial antigens may compete with self-antigens for antigen processing machinery and/or binding to MHC molecules. Lymphocytes proliferating to pathogens might also out-compete self-reactive T cells for cytokines and MHC intereactions needed for survival.
5. Counter-Regulatory Theory: Tstates mircobial infections can induce regulatory T cells that make IL-10 and TGF-beta. here is literature reporting that DCs expressing indoleamine 2,3-dioxygenase (IDO), the rate limiting tryptophan-catalbolizing enzyme induce Treg responses and deplete responding T cells by eliminating tryptophan. (T cells can not make trypotphan, so if break it down, T cells die). Further, adminsitering certain TLR ligands for TLR9 and TLR4 induced IDO and can inhibit experimental asthma (see Rax et al.).
6. Susceptibility genes are shared by multiple autoimmune diseases while others are unique to a particular disease.
7. Depletion of Tregs: Depletion of different CD4+ T cell subsets results in manifestation of different autoimmune disease in mice. For example, depletion of mice of CD25-CD62L+ resulted in gastritis.
8. Aberrant expression of CD86: Several automimmune such as systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) have aberrant CD86 expression.
9. Aberrant expression of chemokines: A hallmark of autoimmunity and other chronic diseases is the overexpression of chemokines, resulting in a detrimental local accumulation of proinflammatory immuen cells.
10. Autoantibodies: Evidence is accumulating that low levels of autantibodies occur in even healthy individuals. Thus any event that will increase their concentration may produce various degrees of pathogenicity. Among the autantibodies identified, special emphasis has ben placed on anti-DNA antibodies. Anti-DNA antibodies are known to be tightly correlated with systemic lups erythematosus (SLE). They tend to fluctuate with disease activity, and high anti-DNA serum titers are often associated with kideny damage. DNA is typically an intracellular component. However, peripheral blood cells can excrete DNA and DNA has been associated with their plasma membrane fraction. DNA receptors have also been described in human platelets and would appear to have a functional role, as their associated with DNA leads to platelet aggregation and serotonin release. Keyhani (Transplantation Proc. 27(5) 1995) isolated DNA associated with Wil2-NS (a non-immunoglobuline secreting human B lymphocyte line) and showed the role of this pmDNA. They did this by studying the presence of IgG in the sera of pateints with various autoimmune diseases directed against Wil2-NS pmDNA.
Treatment Strategies Generally
Self tolerance is though to be kept in check by four main mechanisms: central deletion fo high-avidity autoreactive T or B cell clones; peripheral delection or functional inactivaiton of autoreactive thymic T cell or bone marrow derived B escapees; exportation of mature regulatory T (Treg) cells form the thymus and de novo generation of R reg or regulatory B cells in the periphery. Sera “Antigen-specific therapeutic approaches” Nature Biotechnology, 37, 2019, 238-251)
DNA vaccines: DNA vaccination invovles the transient expression fo antigens in uninfalmed tissues using DNA vectors. For example, DNA vaccination of patients recently diagnosed with type 1 diabetes with an insulin encoding plasmid decreased the peripheral frequency of insulin reactive CD8+T cells and preserved C peptide levels. In another phase 1/2 trial, a DNA vaccine encoding myelin basic protein (MBP; BHT-3009; Bayhill Ehterapeutics) was well tolerated in pateints with MS). Sera “Antigen-specific therapeutic approaches” Nature Biotechnology, 37, 2019, 238-251)
Whole antigens: Clinal testing of whole-antigen immunotherapties autoimmunity have generally been met with failure. Sera “Antigen-specific therapeutic approaches” Nature Biotechnology, 37, 2019, 238-251).
Cell based immunotherapy: Several gruops have used antigen coupled syngeneic lymphoic dells and erythrocytes to promote dominant tolerance. Sera “Antigen-specific therapeutic approaches” Nature Biotechnology, 37, 2019, 238-251)
Nonoparticles for antigen delivery: Nanoparticles have been used as vehicles for antigen delivery to APCs. Sera “Antigen-specific therapeutic approaches” Nature Biotechnology, 37, 2019, 238-251)
Dendritic cell transfer: Specific subsets of DCs support immune tolerance through the generation fo anergic T cells and/or antigen-speciific Treg cells. Sera “Antigen-specific therapeutic approaches” Nature Biotechnology, 37, 2019, 238-251)
Specific Types of Autoimmune Diseases
Antiphospholipid syndrome (APS): show clinical manifestations of severe predisposition to thrombosis. Ritis (J. Immunology, 2006, 177: 4794-4802) show that antiphospholipid Ab induced complement activaiton and downstream signaling via C5a receptors in neutrophils leads to the induction of Tissue Factor (TF), a key initiating component of the blood coagulation cascade.
Primary Immune Thrombocytopenia (ITP) is an autoimmune diesease medaited by antiplatelet antibodies that cause opxonization of platelets and elimination through binding to FcyR-bearing phagocytic cells and subsequent phagocytossi. In additionk the same autoantibodies bind to megakaryocytes and impair platelet prodution. The annual incidince of ITP in the US is about 16000 cases. Although the thrombocytopenia in ITP can be severe, most patients have only minor signs of bleeding. Persistently low platelet counts (<20 x 106/L) however, are associated with an increased risk of serious bleeding, such as intracranial hemorrhage. The inital treatment for ITP is cortisoteroids, IVIg or intravenous RhD immune globulin (anti-D). These compoudns act primarily by interfering with platelet destruction and cytokine modulation. Rozrolimupad, a mixture of 25 recombinant fully human RhD specific mAbs represents a first in class of recombinant human monoclonal antibody mixtures that can be produced independently of human plasma supply. Robak, Blood, 120(18):3670-3676
Myasthenia gravis (MG): is an autoimmune and neurological disorder that affects about 200-400 people per million.
Myastehnia gravis (MG) is a neurological B cell mediated autoimmune disorder affecting the nueromuscular junction. (Vanoli “Ravulizumab for the treatment of myasthenia gravis” Expert Opinion on Biological Therapy” 2023, 23(3).)
–Symptoms
MG is characterized by muscle weakness and fatigability that worsens after their use. Pateints experience muscle weakness and symptoms including drooping eyelids, double vision and slurred speach. For the majority of patients, initial symptoms manifest in the extrinisic ocular muscles of the eye.
A quarter of patients with MG will progress to myasthenic crisis in which paralysis of the respiratory muscles occurs. In such cases, assisted ventilation is required to sustain the life of the affected patients. (Rother, US 15/282,464).
–Causes
MG can result from immune mediated loss of acetylcholine receptors at neuromuscular junctions of skieletal muscle. A large number of patients with MG express antibodies that bind to and inhibit the activity of the nicotinic aceytlcholine recptor (AChR). The antibodies cause loss of acetylcholine receptors and diminished receptor function at the muscle end-late of the nature neuromuscular junction. (Rother, US 15/282,464) Close to 90% of MG patients have antibodies to the AChR. Binding of these antibodies to the receptor results in the failure of skeletal muscle to respond appropriately to nerve stimulation owing to antibody induced injury of the postsynaptic muscle surface. (Kusner, “effector of complement and regulation on myasthenia gravis pathogenesis” Future Drugs Ltd, 2008).
About 80% of patients with MG produce acetylcholine receptor autoantibodies. The other 20% do not, but they do experience the same MG symptoms. Many of the 20% of MG patients without acetylcholine receptor autantibodies instead generate autoantibodies to a membrane protein called MuSK, a specific muscle recptor tyrosine kinase. Athena diagnostics v. Mayo (US Ct Appeals Fed. Cir, 2019). Most patietns (about 85%) display antibodies directed against the nicotinic acetylcholine recetpor (AChR), whereas only 9% present antibodies anti-muscle-specific kinase (muSK) and 1% have antibodies anti-lipoprotein-recetpor related protein 4 (LRP4). Anti-AChr antibodies are minaly ofIgG1 and IgG3 subclass, and thus able to activate the complement cascade which is the main pathogenic mechanism of AChR+ MG. Complement activaiton ultimately leads to the disruption of the postsynaptic folds with loss of dispersion of AChRs. Another important pathogenic mechaism is antigenic modulation, where bivalent antibodies crosslink AChRs with acceleration of AChR endocytosis and degradation. Finally, anti-AChR antibodies act also by directly blocking the acetylcholine binding site on AChRs. Anti-MuSK antibodies, on the other hand, are of IgG4 subclass and thus unable to activate complement cascade and induce antigenic modulation as they are funcitonally monovalent. Their pathogenic effect is exerted by masking the binding sites in MuSK that interact with LRP4 and collagen Q, which is essential for AChR clustering. Indded, the inactivation of MUSK leads to a decrease of AChR density and an impairment of their alignemnt on the postsynaptic membrane. Anti-LRP4 are of IgG1 subclass and are thus able to activate the complement cascade. Moreover, these antiboides also inhibit AChR clustering, by blocking the agrin-LRP4 interaction. Finally, a small percentage of MG patients are defined as serongegative, as no specific pathogenic antibody has been identified. Vanoli “Ravulizumab for the treatment of myasthenia gravis” Expert Opinion on Biological Therapy” 2023, 23(3).)
The activation by antibody ultimately leads to formation of the membrane attack complex (MAC) that produces cell lysis and, in Mg, produces focal damage of the postsynaptic surface of of the muscle, which ultimately compromises neuromuscular transmission. (Soltys, “Extraocular muscle susceptibility to myasthenia gravis” Ann. Ny.Y. Acad. Sci, 1132, 220-224, 2008).
Pathophysiology of complemetn activation in MG:
Anti-acetylcholine (Ach) recetpor (AChR) antibodies activate the complemetn cascade thorugh the classical pathway by bnidng C1q on the Fc domain. The subsequence formation of C5 convertase initates the temrinal pathway which ultimately leads to the formation of the membrane attack complex (MAC), a lytic pore on the posynaptic membrane. The final effect is a focal lysis of the nuromusclar junction with disruption of the postsynaptic folds and loss of AChRs. Antibodies such as Ravulizumab (see below) binds with high affintiy to C5, inhibiting the enzymatic clevage and thereby preventing the MAC formation. Vanoli “Ravulizumab for the treatment of myasthenia gravis” Expert Opinion on Biological Therapy” 2023, 23(3).)
–Treatment:
Autoimmune attack is dependent on T cells, resulting from loss of tolerance toward self antigens at the level of the tymus. However, Abs and complement are key effectors of the loss of possynaptic AChRs and associated desstruction of the NJM. Tehrefore, the goal of MG treatment is to interrup the autoimmune prcoess by T cells and B cells using corticosteroids, thymectomy, IVIg and immunosuppressants. (Kim, J. Clin. Neurol 2011; 7: 173-183).
MG is characterized by remarkable clinical variability, and no one treatment can be predicted to have the same beneficial (or toxic) effect on all patients. (Sanders, Autoimmunity August -September 2010, 43 (5-6), 428-435).
—-Anti-C5 (eculizumab, Ravulizumab, etc):
Andrien (US 2017/0298123) discloses that BNJ441 (“Ravulizumab”) relative to exulizumab contains four amino acid substitutions in the H chain, Tyr-27-His, Ser-57-His, Met-429-Leu and Asn-435 Ser (note that positions 429 and 435 of BNJ441 correspond to positions 428 and 434 uner the EU numbering system). These mutations were engineered to enable an extended dosing interval verus exulizumab by increasing the circulating half-life by reducing antibody clearance and increasing the eficiency o f the FcRn-medaited antibody recylcing. Adrian teaches that the antibodies are useful for treating a variety of complement associated disorders such as aHUS, PNH and myasthenia gravis.
Bedrosian (US Patent Application NO: 15/595,890, published as US 2017/0342139) discloses methods of treating myasthenia gravis (MG) in a patient positive for auto-antibodies binding to nicotinic acetylcholine receptor by administering eculizumab using a phase dosing schedule with an induction phase comprising 900 mg on day 1, 900 mg odses on days 7, 14, and 21 and 1200 mg as a fifth induction dose on day 28 wherein the patient is administered eculizumab for at least 26 weeks and wehrien the 28 day induction phase of eclizumab is followed by a minatenance phase of 1200 mg of eculizumab 14 days after the fift induciton dose and 200 mg eveyr 14 days therafter. 60 kg, 3300 mg to a patient weighing 60-100 kg or 3600 mg to a patient weighing greater than 100 kg.
Fujita (US Patent Application No: 16/791,415, published as US 2020/0331993) discloses a method of treating myasthenia gravis (MG) with an anti-C5 antibody such as Ravulizumab (also known as antibody GNJ441, ALXN1210 or Ultomiris) based on weight. At day 1, 2400 mg to a patient weighing 40-60 kg, 2700 mg for a pateint weighing 60-100 kg and 3000 mg for a patient weighing greater than 100 kg. On day 15 and every 8 weeks thereafter a miantenance dose of aslo based on weight; 3000 mg to a patient weighing 40-
Rother (US Patent Application No: 15/282,464, published as US 20170015740) discloses compositions containing an inhibitor of the complement component C5 such as the antibody eculizumab sold by Alexion Pharmaceuticals for treating MG. In one embodiment, the anti-C5 antibody is adminsitered at a doese of about 600 mg every week for two or more weeks followed by 900 mg about every 14 days.
(NIHR Horizon Scanning Research & Intelligence Center “Eculizumab (Soliris) for refractory myasthenia gravis, March 2016. discloses eulizumab adminsitered IV at 1,200 mg every 2 weeks according to a schedule of randomised 900 mg IV once weekly for 4 weeks, followed by 1,200 mg IV every 2 weeks for weeks 5-26 for treatent of MG
Zhou (“anti-C5 antibody treatment ameliorates weakness in experimentally acquired myasthenia gravis” J. Immunol. (2007) discloses that in rats induced with AChR Ab, an anti-C5 mAbrestored strenght in two thirds of the rats.
—-Immunosuppressive drugs:
Most nuerologists consider some form of immunosuppression to be essential to the treatment of MG, however, there is no general concensus about which drug should be used, in which patients, and when. Corticosteroid exert profound immunosuppression by inducing T lymphocyte apoptosis, repressing transcription of inflammatory cytokines and impairing DC maturation. Corticosteroid were the first immunosuppressants used in MG therpay and are still used (i.e., prednisone) in most patients tarting with high daily doses adn then shifting to alternate day adminsitration. Remission (30%) or marked improvement (45%) occurs isn over 3/4 of patients, a further 15% have some lesser degree of improvement. (Sanders, Autoimmunity August -September 2010, 43 (5-6), 428-435)
—-Thymectomy:
Thymoma is reprotedly found in 10-30 of patients with MG. Thymectomy is associated with clinical improvement in 85% of cases and 35% of pateints appear to ahve complete remission. Thymectomy is used in non-thymomatous myasthenia to improve symptoms and in the hope of reducign subsequent drug burden. (NIHR Horizon Scanning Research & Intelligence Center “Eculizumab (Soliris) for refractory myasthenia gravis, March 2016.
Narcolepsy:
Narcolepsy is thought to be an autoimmune disorder where the immune system destroys certain brain cells that produce a peptide called heptocritin. Symptoms include excessive daytime sleeping and cataplexy (muscles become suddently weak or lymph).
The FDA has approved the drug Xyrem for treatment of Narcolepsy. However, because this product contains gamma hydroxybutyrate (GHB) it is classified as a Schedule III depressants. 21 CFR 1308.13 and one must register to receive the drug.
Hereditary angioedema (HAE): is a disease caused by deficiency of the CP control protein, C1-Inh. These individuals have recurrent swelling in the extremities, face, lips, larynx or GI tract. The patients suffer form a felling of fullness but not pain or itching in the affected area except for those with abdominal swellings who often experience acute abdominal pain. The latter two presentations are of the most concern because suffocation can occur if the airways are obstructed, and the acute swelling of the abdominal region produces intense pain often resulting in exploratory surgery. The mechanisms for production of the swelling involves not the complement enzymes, but the kinin-generating pathway. It is the product of Bradykinin through this pathway that is responsible for the tissue permeability changes that cause the swelling. Acute trematnets include C1 inhibiotr (C1-INH, Berienrt) or a replacement thrapy; ecallntide, a kallikrein inibitor;a nd icatibant, a bradykinin-2 receptor antagonist. Prophylactic treatments include attenuated adrogens and C1 inhihibor. (US Patent Applicaiton No: 15/895,551, published as US 2019/0247560).